This is a copy from the site https://lordsmobile.weebly.com/teeny-titans-figure-list.html but that page has been taken down, so I’m reproducing it here in case I need it in the future :)

  1. Robin: Alfred’s Toy Cave
  2. Cyborg: Alfred’s Toy Cave & Kords N Wires
  3. Raven: Alfred’s Toy Cave & Zinthos
  4. Starfire: Alfred’s Toy Cave
  5. Beast Boy: Alfred’s Toy Cave & Toyman
  6. Silkie: Toyman
  7. 80s Robin: Toyman
  8. 80s Cyborg: Kords N Wires & LexToys
  9. 80s Raven: Zinthos
  10. 80s Starfire: Bizarro Comics
  11. 80s Beast Boy: Toyman, Beach Shop & LexToys
  12. Old School Silkie: Reward from first Tofu Tony mission & Buy from Sticky Joe
  13. Gizmo: Shady District 24-Hr Shop, Kords N Wires & Jailbird Toys
  14. Jinx: Zinthos, Jailbird Toys & LexToys
  15. Mammoth: Toyman
  16. See-more: Alfred’s Toy Cave
  17. Billy Numerous: Alfred’s Toy Cave, 24-HR Shop & Bizarro Comics
  18. Dr. Light: Shady District 24-HR Shop, Buy from Sticky Joe, Kords N Wires & Jailbird Toys
  19. Blackfire: Alfred’s Toy Cave, Shady District 24-HR Shop & Bizarro Comics
  20. Bumblebee: Alfred’s Toy Cave & Bizarro Comics
  21. Serious Bumblebee: Reward for burying George Washington & LexToys
  22. Kid Flash: Flash Store (7 tickets)
  23. Aqualad: Beach Shop
  24. Pirate Aqualad: LexToys
  25. Speedy: Toyman & Bizarro Comics
  26. Red Arrow: Defeat Speedy
  27. Sticky Joe: Defeat Sticky Joe & LexToys
  28. Red X: Shady District 24-HR Shop, Bizarro Comics & Jailbird Toys
  29. Cyborg’s Head: Kords N Wires
  30. Lady Legasus: Toyman
  31. Starfire the Terrible: Zinthos & LexToys
  32. Cat Beast Boy: Reward for Defeating three dogs mission & Toyman
  33. Princess Silkie: Toyman
  34. Mother Mae-Eye: Zinthos, Shady District 24-HR Shop & Jailbird Toys
  35. Other Mae-Eye: Zinthos
  36. Terra: Defeat Terra in Uppity Uptown Tournament & Jailbird Toys
  37. Brother Blood: Shady District 24-HR Shop, Kords N Wires, Jailbird Toys & LexToys
  38. Robotic Brother Blood: Complete Dr. Light’s mission & LexToys
  39. Monsieur Mallah: Jailbird Toys
  40. Rose Wilson: Jailbird Toys & LexToys
  41. Killer Moth: Jailbird Toys
  42. Trigon: Zinthos
  43. Argyle Trigon: Defeat Trigon in Uppity Uptown
  44. Nightwing: Bizarro Comics & LexToys
  45. Dad Nightwing: Toyman
  46. Bat Robin: LexToys
  47. Green Cyborg: Defeating the Annoying Kid with 3 80s figs & Mystery Figures
  48. Wonder Raven: Bizarro Comics & LexToys
  49. StarFlash: Reward for completing mission to get 10 Flash tickets & costs 10 tickets at Flash Store
  50. Martian Beast Boy: Bizarro Comics
  51. Super Silkie: LexToys
  52. B’wana Beast: Beach Shop
  53. George Washington: Toyman
  54. Santa Claus: Defeat Santa Claus (Shady District nighttime)
  55. Artemis: Reach rank 20 at the JLA Recruitment Center
  56. Blue Beetle: Achieve Rank 5 at the JLA Recruitment Office (Justice League)
  57. Darkseid: Complete Scamiand’r’s scam mail mission/quest & Jailbird Toys
  58. Batgirl: Bizarro Comics
  59. Alfred: Buy at Saphire’s shop for $3000
  60. Killer Croc: Find the Tofu Guy and he’ll ask you to find the alligators in the sewers. Just warp around the sewers a few times to find Killer Croc. You’ll have to find him twice and then defeat him in battle to get the fig. You can also find the figure at Jailbird Toys.
  61. Black Manta: Bizarro Comics
  62. Aquaman: Saphire’s
  63. Multiverse Robin: Toyman & Saphire’s
  64. Multiverse Cyborg: Saphire’s
  65. Multiverse Raven: Deliver motivational card to Raven
  66. Multiverse Starfire: Complete all of Starfire’s missions
  67. Multiverse Beast Boy: Defeat Uppity Uptown Beast Boy using any 3 Beast Boy figs
  68. Multiverse Silkie: Saphire’s
  69. Multiverse Gizmo: Complete all Gizmo missions
  70. Multiverse Jinx: Defeat Jinx in Jailhouse Tournament
  71. Multiverse Sticky Joe: Buy from Sticky Joe
  72. Multiverse B’wana Beast: Defeat B’wana Beast on his island
  73. Harley Quinn: Bizarro Comics (You may have to complete all of Commissioner Gordon’s quests to access it. You get to keep the one from that quest, though, so it’s worth waiting either way.)
  74. Joker: Bizarro Comics for $9000
  75. Bizarro: Rank 50 at JLA Recruitment Center Building
  76. The Hooded Hood: Win the final tournament and defeat the Hooded Hood
  77. Mr. Chibi: Defeat Mr. Chibi